Intrinsic Image Diffusion User Study - Results

This is a gallery of the images used in the user study, together with the results.

Summary
9.62962962962963%
Bell et al. 2014
0.4629629629629629%
Li et al. 2020
6.111111111111111%
Zhu et al. 2022
83.79629629629629%
Ours
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
3.7037037037037033%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
88.88888888888889%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
29.629629629629626%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
62.96296296296296%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
11.11111111111111%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
81.48148148148148%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
11.11111111111111%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
3.7037037037037033%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
29.629629629629626%
Ours
Ours
55.55555555555556%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
0.0%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
3.7037037037037033%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
0.0%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
96.29629629629629%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
11.11111111111111%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
85.18518518518519%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
7.4074074074074066%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
85.18518518518519%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
88.88888888888889%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
0.0%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
3.7037037037037033%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
7.4074074074074066%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
11.11111111111111%
Ours
Ours
81.48148148148148%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
48.148148148148145%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
44.44444444444444%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
0.0%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
14.814814814814813%
Ours
Ours
85.18518518518519%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
14.814814814814813%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
77.77777777777779%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
7.4074074074074066%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
88.88888888888889%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
7.4074074074074066%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
85.18518518518519%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
11.11111111111111%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
81.48148148148148%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
14.814814814814813%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
81.48148148148148%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
33.33333333333333%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
62.96296296296296%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
22.22222222222222%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
74.07407407407408%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
11.11111111111111%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
85.18518518518519%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
3.7037037037037033%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
88.88888888888889%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
11.11111111111111%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
85.18518518518519%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
88.88888888888889%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
0.0%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
11.11111111111111%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
11.11111111111111%
Ours
Ours
77.77777777777779%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
18.51851851851852%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
74.07407407407408%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
7.4074074074074066%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
88.88888888888889%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
0.0%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
96.29629629629629%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
7.4074074074074066%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
88.88888888888889%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
22.22222222222222%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
74.07407407407408%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
18.51851851851852%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
7.4074074074074066%
Ours
Ours
74.07407407407408%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
3.7037037037037033%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
92.5925925925926%
Input
Input
Bell et al. 2014
Bell et al. 2014
0.0%
Li et al. 2020
Li et al. 2020
0.0%
Zhu et al. 2022
Zhu et al. 2022
3.7037037037037033%
Ours
Ours
96.29629629629629%